The Truth About Trucking Insurance Loss Runs: Why "We Just Need Your Loss Runs" Isn't Actually a Quote
- StartMyTruckingCompany
- Jul 18
- 5 min read
If you've been shopping for commercial truck insurance recently, you've probably heard something like this:
"Absolutely. We can beat your current insurance. Just send me your loss runs."
It sounds promising.
It sounds like the insurance agency already knows they can save you money.
The reality is...
They don't.
At Start My Trucking Company, we hear this almost every day from trucking companies calling for a second opinion. Many owner-operators and fleet owners believe they've already received a quote when, in reality, they haven't received anything more than an invitation to begin the underwriting process.
There is a huge difference.
Understanding that difference can save you thousands of dollars, weeks of frustration, and potentially keep your trucking company from ending up in the wrong insurance program.
What Are Trucking Insurance Loss Runs?
Loss runs are simply your insurance history.
Think of them as your report card.
They tell an insurance company:
• How long you've been insured
• Every claim you've reported
• How much each claim paid
• Whether claims are still open
• How frequently you've filed claims
• Whether your insurance history fits the carrier's appetite
Loss runs are extremely important.
But here's the first misconception.
Loss runs do not create a quote.
Loss runs create an underwriting submission.
Those are two completely different things.
"We Just Need Your Loss Runs" Is Not the Same as "We Can Quote You"
This is probably the biggest misunderstanding in commercial trucking insurance.
Many agencies advertise that they can beat your current premium.
Then they immediately ask for:
• Loss Runs
• Driver Lists
• Vehicle Schedules
• MVRs
• Current Declarations
• Years of Insurance History
Why?
Because they don't actually know whether the insurance company they're planning to approach will even accept your account.
The underwriter has to answer that question first.
Only after your file is reviewed does pricing begin.
In other words...
The quote doesn't exist yet.
Why Do Some Insurance Companies Require Loss Runs?
Insurance companies that require loss runs generally aren't designed for brand-new trucking companies.
Many are underwriting established businesses with operating history, prior insurance experience, and documented claims performance. Several transportation market guides distinguish between true new venture programs and more seasoned accounts that require underwriting history before pricing.
That doesn't make these markets bad.
In fact, they can be an excellent fit for experienced trucking companies.
But they're often a completely different conversation than a new authority looking for insurance.
New Authority Insurance Is Different
If you've just received your DOT Number or MC Authority, you usually need a true new venture program.
These programs are specifically built for companies with little or no insurance history. For example, some carrier programs have dedicated "Freshman New Ventures" guidelines that outline eligibility for operations with zero years in business.
That's a very different underwriting process than submitting three years of valued loss runs.
If an agency immediately asks a brand-new authority for loss runs, ask yourself one simple question.
"What loss runs?"
You don't have any.
Here's the Question You Should Always Ask
Instead of asking...
"Can you beat my insurance?"
Ask this.
"Do you already know which carrier can quote me, or are you collecting information to see if anyone will?"
That one question changes the entire conversation.
A professional insurance agency should be honest about the process.
Sometimes the answer is:
"We have a market that looks promising."
Other times the answer is:
"We need underwriting approval before we know."
There's nothing wrong with either answer.
What's important is transparency.
Understanding Premium Financing
Let's say your account is accepted.
Many trucking companies are surprised to learn they're not paying the insurance company directly.
Instead, a premium finance company may pay the annual premium upfront, and you repay that finance company in monthly installments.
Now your insurance involves multiple parties.
• Your insurance agency
• The insurance carrier
• The premium finance company
• Sometimes a wholesale broker as well
Each plays a different role.
Many finance agreements require a larger down payment than direct-billed policies, and the exact amount depends on the carrier, finance company, and the risk being insured.
Understanding who you're paying—and why—is important before you sign.
What Is a Pro-Rated Premium?
This surprises trucking companies every day.
Let's say you buy insurance in January.
In June, you purchase another truck.
You're not buying another twelve-month policy.
You're buying coverage for the remaining months of your current policy term.
That's called a pro-rated premium.
Depending on how your policy is financed, you may also owe an additional down payment on that new premium.
Many owners aren't expecting that.
Knowing it ahead of time prevents unnecessary surprises.
Ask About Agency Fees
One item that often catches trucking companies off guard is an agency fee or broker fee.
Not every agency charges one.
Not every policy includes one.
But if your proposal lists an additional fee outside of the insurance premium, ask questions.
• What is this fee?
• Who receives it?
• Is it refundable?
• Why isn't it included in the premium?
A good agency should have no problem explaining every dollar on your proposal.
Don't Assume an ELD Automatically Means Lower Rates
Another common sales pitch sounds like this.
"Upload your Samsara."
"Send us your Motive login."
"We'll get you a cheaper quote."
Electronic Logging Devices can absolutely help some insurance companies better understand a trucking operation.
But an ELD is only one piece of underwriting.
It doesn't erase claims.
It doesn't change years in business.
It doesn't remove safety violations.
It doesn't guarantee lower pricing.
If someone promises a dramatically lower premium based solely on an ELD, ask what else is changing.
Think Beyond Today's Price
Every trucking company wants to save money.
That's smart.
But don't focus only on the monthly payment.
Ask about:
• Billing options
• Claims process
• Down payment requirements
• Premium financing
• Agency fees
• Coverage endorsements
• Future truck additions
• Customer service
The cheapest policy on Day One isn't always the least expensive policy over the next twelve months.
Final Thoughts
Loss runs are an important part of commercial trucking insurance.
They help insurance companies understand your history.
But they are not a guarantee that a quote exists.
Before you spend time gathering paperwork, make sure you understand where you are in the process.
Are you receiving an actual insurance quote?
Or are you beginning an underwriting review?
Knowing the difference helps you ask better questions, avoid unnecessary surprises, and choose the insurance program that's truly right for your trucking company.
At Start My Trucking Company, we believe education comes before sales.
The more you understand how commercial trucking insurance works, the better decisions you'll make for your business—not just today, but for years to come.
Call a trucking specialist at (786) 358-3661
Follow us on Facebook:facebook.com/startmytruckingcompany
Comments